There is a good old saying that is most appropriate — " It is no use spoiling the
ship for the sake of a ha'porth of tar."
Do not let me be misunderstood on this point. I do not for one moment mean
that it is necessary to have old-bottled wine or wine of any particularly good vintage,
but what I mean is, it must be wine, and what I maintain is, that too often what is
put in soups is not Avine at all. The best sherry foi' the purpose is golden sherry,
and not a pale dry wine.
Since the vineyards at Madeira have recovered, it is quite possible to get a cheap
rich full wine, not fit to drink in fact at present, but nevertheless the very thing for
soup. I should be glad if some of my readers would try the following experiment: —
Have some good clear mock turtle soup made ; taste it before the wine is put to it —
suppose the qixantity to be three quarts. Add a tumblerful of madeira✪ Mock Turtle Soup, and then
tfiste, and let them ask themselves whether the difference in the flavour is not well
woi'th the money.
PRINCIPLES — SOUP.
There are several soups that will bear, and be very mucli imijroved by, the
addition of sherry, and we would mention soup made from calves' feet or ox-feet,
giblet soup, and soup made from any kind of game. A very good rough test of the
value of adding sherry to mock-turtle soup is a pastrycook's. Let any one order
a basin of soup and a glass of sherry for lunch, and add a table-spoonful of the
shexTy to the soup — the lesson learnt will be worth the probable eighteen-pence
paid. While on the subject of adding \Ane to soups I would mention hare soup,
which is not really, or should not be, a thick soup, though of course it could not
be called clear. Hai-e soup requires port wine, and not sherry, and of course the
same observations that applied to sheny apply to the port. If you cannot
afford or obtain real port, don't put in any bad wine to spoil the hare. In France
Burgundy is used for dressing hare; but in England the imitation port is, if
anything, a more horrible compound than the imitation sherry. What the effect
of adding this compound to hare soup would be I camiot say, beyond that it
would be as certain to spoil it as an equal quantity of blacking would. Hare
will bear a large quantity of port wine. One of the greatest living cooks recom-
mends half a bottle of port wine to one single hare. This is extravagant; but
there is no doubt that the soup would be all the better for it. I would here
mention the fact that whenever port wine is used in cooking, a few cloves, a
very little piece of cinnamon, and a little lemon-juice✪ Hare Soup may always be added with
advantage. The gi-eat secret of success in making good hare soup is rubbing the
meat well through a tamis, or wire sieve. The best part of the meat should of
course be kept to add to the soup after it is made, while all the bones, &c.,
should be well stewed, and after the bones, which have been boiled till they are
dry and white, have been taken out, all the meat and celery with which they have
been boiled should be rubbed through a wire sieve with a wooden spoon. Hare
soup requires no thickening.
Page 42 · 2 recipe records on this page
Presented as published in 1892. Historical recipes may not meet modern food-safety standards. Cook from the modern interpretation, not the original instructions.
AI-modernized reading of the original text
A modernized reading is not available for this page yet. You are seeing the original text.
There is a good old saying that is most appropriate — " It is no use spoiling the
ship for the sake of a ha'porth of tar."
Do not let me be misunderstood on this point. I do not for one moment mean
that it is necessary to have old-bottled wine or wine of any particularly good vintage,
but what I mean is, it must be wine, and what I maintain is, that too often what is
put in soups is not Avine at all. The best sherry foi' the purpose is golden sherry,
and not a pale dry wine.
Since the vineyards at Madeira have recovered, it is quite possible to get a cheap
rich full wine, not fit to drink in fact at present, but nevertheless the very thing for
soup. I should be glad if some of my readers would try the following experiment: —
Have some good clear mock turtle soup made ; taste it before the wine is put to it —
suppose the qixantity to be three quarts. Add a tumblerful of madeira, and then
tfiste, and let them ask themselves whether the difference in the flavour is not well
woi'th the money.
PRINCIPLES — SOUP.
There are several soups that will bear, and be very mucli imijroved by, the
addition of sherry, and we would mention soup made from calves' feet or ox-feet,
giblet soup, and soup made from any kind of game. A very good rough test of the
value of adding sherry to mock-turtle soup is a pastrycook's. Let any one order
a basin of soup and a glass of sherry for lunch, and add a table-spoonful of the
shexTy to the soup — the lesson learnt will be worth the probable eighteen-pence
paid. While on the subject of adding \Ane to soups I would mention hare soup,
which is not really, or should not be, a thick soup, though of course it could not
be called clear. Hai-e soup requires port wine, and not sherry, and of course the
same observations that applied to sheny apply to the port. If you cannot
afford or obtain real port, don't put in any bad wine to spoil the hare. In France
Burgundy is used for dressing hare; but in England the imitation port is, if
anything, a more horrible compound than the imitation sherry. What the effect
of adding this compound to hare soup would be I camiot say, beyond that it
would be as certain to spoil it as an equal quantity of blacking would. Hare
will bear a large quantity of port wine. One of the greatest living cooks recom-
mends half a bottle of port wine to one single hare. This is extravagant; but
there is no doubt that the soup would be all the better for it. I would here
mention the fact that whenever port wine is used in cooking, a few cloves, a
very little piece of cinnamon, and a little lemon-juice may always be added with
advantage. The gi-eat secret of success in making good hare soup is rubbing the
meat well through a tamis, or wire sieve. The best part of the meat should of
course be kept to add to the soup after it is made, while all the bones, &c.,
should be well stewed, and after the bones, which have been boiled till they are
dry and white, have been taken out, all the meat and celery with which they have
been boiled should be rubbed through a wire sieve with a wooden spoon. Hare
soup requires no thickening.